The barn was too small to suggest a serious car collection. Mike Maurer followed a retired medical doctor outside, watched him pull back a cover and found a pristine 1967 Porsche 911 S underneath. The same man had owned it for 50 years. This was no car polished for an auction photograph or passed among dealers. It was an original-owner Porsche with its history intact.
The same man had owned it for 50 years.
Years later, Mike sold that 911 S for $75,000 to pay his children's college tuition. The buyer took it to Australia and gave Mike first right of refusal if it ever returned to the market. When that opportunity came, the asking price was $200,000. Mike had acquired the car for about $20,000. It was still familiar and still wanted, but now far beyond the terms of their original agreement.
A covered 1967 Porsche 911 S in a tiny barn
The connection began with an Audi A8, not a Porsche. Mike sold the large Audi A8 to a retired medical doctor without knowing the client had a 1967 Porsche 911 S at home. As they became friends, the owner realized Mike was a Porsche man and invited him over to see one of his cars. About a month later, Mike visited and followed him outside to what he called a "small little barn."
When the cover came off, Mike's mouth fell open. The 911 S was pristine, and the man beside it was the original owner. He had kept the Porsche for 50 years. With an older car, that continuity removes much of the usual uncertainty. There were no conflicting accounts from five previous owners and no questions about when major pieces had disappeared. The owner and the car had remained together.
This was not a conventional barn-find chase. Mike had not knocked on random doors, placed wanted advertisements or arrived with a trailer and cash. The discovery grew out of a friendship that lasted a couple of years. During that time, the owner faced a family dispute: his three daughters were fighting over who would receive the Porsche. He believed none of them would care for it properly. Mike's habit of keeping cars as close to perfect as possible earned him the original owner's confidence.
The unusual deal that put stewardship ahead of price
The transfer began over dinner with the owner and his wife, Julie. The owner did not ask whether Mike wanted the Porsche or invite him to make an offer. He said, "Mike, you're going to buy the red car." Mike answered honestly: he could not afford it. The response was equally direct. The owner told him not to worry about the cost. He wanted Mike to have it because Mike cared about the car and would not let it deteriorate.
He said, "Mike, you're going to buy the red car."
Most collector-car sales do not work that way. Ordinarily, buyer and seller agree on a price, inspect the car, arrange payment and complete the handover. Here, personal trust replaced a fixed payment schedule. Mike sent small amounts when that was all he could manage, larger sums when he could afford more, and sometimes stopped by the house with a payment. He estimates that he ultimately paid about $20,000 for the 1967 Porsche 911 S.
The arrangement worked because the owner had seen how Mike treated cars. Mike had spent years buying Porsche cars, maintaining them carefully and trading into newer examples without neglecting the outgoing car. He also knew the product from the dealership side, where condition, specification and history separate a special car from an ordinary used one. The original owner was not giving the 911 S to someone planning a quick retail turn. Mike kept it for 17 years.
College tuition, Australia and a $200,000 second chance
After 17 years, Mike sold the Porsche to pay his children's college tuition. The decision is easy to second-guess after seeing the later price, but the need was specific and immediate. He knew he would miss the car before it left, yet $75,000 looked like a great deal of money. A car can remain a keeper until a family obligation requires the money tied up in it. That is a difficult calculation, but not a complicated one.
A car can remain a keeper until a family obligation requires the money tied up in it.
The buyer took the 1967 Porsche 911 S to Australia, but the sale did not end their relationship. Mike and the new owner stayed in touch, and the buyer gave him first right of refusal if he decided to sell. That promise left a narrow route back to the exact car. It was not simply another red 911 S from the same year, but the original-owner car from the small little barn, which Mike had paid for over time and maintained for 17 years.
When Mike was later in a position to ask about buying it back, the answer reflected the changed market. The Australian owner wanted $200,000. Mike pointed out that he had sold it for $75,000 and that the buyer had not put another $125,000 into it. The buyer did not claim otherwise. $200,000 was simply his price. Mike answered, "Keep it." The friendship survived, as did the first right of refusal, but the Porsche remained in Australia. Mike jokes that if the market crashes, he will call. Until then, the hard part is not knowing what the car became worth. It is knowing exactly which car it is, where it went and what bringing it home would cost.