A champagne cork struck Dr. Robert Kearns in the left eye on his wedding night. The injury left him permanently blind in that eye, though he retained peripheral vision and could still drive. Every blink hurt. As he looked through a windshield, he wondered why the wipers could not behave like the human eye: moving when needed, then resting. The intermittent windshield wiper electronic control grew from that connection between physical pain and an ordinary mechanical problem.
Within a couple of days, Dr. Robert Kearns had created the central circuit. But the speed and apparent simplicity of the work gave no indication of what would follow: guarded demonstrations, patent lawsuits, disputes over a settlement and a 30-year struggle that eventually pulled all six Kearns children away from their own careers. A device that introduced a measured delay into a windshield wiper consumed decades of family life.
A device that introduced a measured delay into a windshield wiper consumed decades of family life.
An eye injury sparked the intermittent wiper invention
Why should a windshield wiper move continuously through light rain? Dr. Robert Kearns's question was more specific than a general desire for improvement. His injured eye blinked intermittently rather than sweeping without pause, providing a model in his own body. He imagined a wiper that could stop between movements in much the same way, clearing the windshield without maintaining a constant rhythm.
He had the technical knowledge to turn that observation into electronics. In 1963, Dr. Robert Kearns was working with transistors at Bendix, when relatively few people were doing so, according to Timothy Kearns. He used a transistor as the on-off switch that created the delay in the intermittent windshield wiper electronic control. The essential circuit emerged in a couple of days from a direct combination of experience, a precise question and technical knowledge.
The invention's simplicity was its strength, but that simplicity also created a problem. A compact circuit can make an idea seem obvious after someone has built it, even when nobody had previously made the same connection. Timothy Kearns said the circuit's simplicity began to haunt his father. What looked straightforward in retrospect became difficult to defend as the work of a particular inventor. The delay was technically modest. Claiming ownership of it was not.
The delay was technically modest. Claiming ownership of it was not.
Ford wanted to see the circuit Kearns kept hidden
Dr. Robert Kearns secured an initial patent and began searching for a manufacturer, eventually accumulating thirty-some patents. He gained access to Ford through an unusually close connection: his brother was a vice president of one of the company's divisions and helped arrange a presentation. That family connection opened the door, but it did not resolve the difficult question inside the room. How much could an inventor safely reveal to the company capable of manufacturing his idea?
Ford invited Dr. Robert Kearns to demonstrate how the wiper worked. The movement of the blades was not the main point of interest. The essential knowledge sat inside the concealed circuit. Timothy Kearns recalled that Ford repeatedly asked to see it and even tried to trick his father into revealing it. Dr. Robert Kearns kept it hidden. He understood that the difference between demonstrating an invention and surrendering its operating details might amount to a removed cover or an answered question.
The imbalance was plain. One man had an initial patent and a simple circuit; a major automaker had the means to put that control in cars. Each wanted something from the other, but they did not enter the meeting with equal power. The guarded demonstration contained the conflict that would follow: Ford's repeated efforts to inspect the circuit, Dr. Robert Kearns's refusal to expose it and an idea whose simplicity made it both useful and vulnerable.
Each wanted something from the other, but they did not enter the meeting with equal power.
Six children became the Kearns board of directors
The patent lawsuits did not remain Dr. Robert Kearns's private undertaking. His six children became, in the family's irreverent description, the Kearns Corporation's board of directors.They listened as law professors helped their father learn to act as a lawyer, picking up the language and demands of the legal system alongside him. Timothy Kearns later said each sibling became "sort of a piece of a lawyer." Dennis Kearns, for example, became a private detective familiar with evidence and what a defense might require.
That education came at a severe price. After building careers of their own, the children left them to help their father, participating 100% in the fight. Timothy Kearns said the Ford case and Chrysler case each lasted five years, while the full struggle continued for 30 years. Around the family table, they argued over whether to accept a settlement. The decision forced them to weigh legal endurance against work, money and years they could never recover.
The decision forced them to weigh legal endurance against work, money and years they could never recover.
Dr. Robert Kearns insisted the fight would make a difference for inventors, and Timothy Kearns described the litigation as seminal to modern patent law. The 2008 film Flash of Genius, with Greg Kinnear portraying Dr. Robert Kearns, moved Timothy Kearns deeply when he saw his father's life dramatized. A film, however, compresses what the family lived through. The cost is clearer in the details: six children, abandoned careers, two five-year cases and a 30-year refusal to accept that the circuit could simply be taken.